Language Differences that Matter a Lot

When people discuss the disparities in opportunity among socio-economic groups, the research done by Betty Hart and Todd Risley in the 80’s and 90’s often comes up (Hart & Risley, Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experience of Young American Children, 1995). These researchers carefully studied poor children and school success. In order to do this they looked at the family lives of children prior to preschool. Todd Risley explains that

“children are awake (and able to learn) about 100 to 110 hours in every week of life, they would have already used up over 15,000 hours of learning opportunity time by age three. We wanted to know how full or empty of learning experience were those hours of opportunity—and to compare the lives of babies from the poorest families with the lives of babies from working-class and professional families.” (Risley & Hart, 2006)

We all know the importance of those early experiences, but sometimes forget how precious those 15,000 hours are and how quickly that time can escape a busy parent. Growing Great Kids curriculum materials are designed specifically to support parents in making the most of each of these opportunities. By practicing the Daily Do’s dozens of times each day, they will be supporting their child’s optimum development.

The findings from the research of Hart and Risely are immense and can be read in their entirety in their book Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experience of Young American Children (Hart & Risley, Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experience of Young American Children, 1995). Many of the findings in regard to language are extremely important to the work of Family Support workers and are the basis for the Prenatal to 36 month Growing Great Kids Daily Do: Play by Play and the Preschool Growing Great Kids Daily Do: Talk it Up.

One of the most critical findings was that there are consistently very large differences between families and the amount of time, encouragement, and talk their children are exposed to. (Hart & Risley, The early catasrophe: The 30 million word gap by age 3, 2003) Some parents spend as much as 40 minutes out of each hour interacting with their babies, and others spend as little as 15 minutes out of each hour. Some parents encouraged or expressed approval to their babies 40 times in an hour, while others it was less than 4 times an hour. Some parents spoke over 3000 words compared to others who said fewer than 200 words in an average hour. (Risley & Hart, 2006) It’s important to note that these differences were consistent across time for each family so the different early exposure to language for each baby really adds up. By the time these children started preschool, the number of words their parents had spoken to them were hugely different, 33 million in some families compared to only 10 million in other families. Some children, by the age of three would have already heard over 500,000 positive statements about their actions and other children less than 60,000 affirmative statements.

Another important research finding was that “extra” talk is automatically both more positive and more complex. (Risley & Hart, 2006) All parents of young children were found to use similar numbers of basic “business” talk. This includes things like “stop that”, “hold still”, “come here”, and “put that down.” That part wasn’t so surprising, but what was interesting was that they found that whenever parents talked more than necessary for just taking care of business…it was more conversational and the running commentary was automatically “more rich in the varied vocabulary, complex ideas, subtle guidance, and positive reinforcement that are thought to be important to intellectual development.” (Risley & Hart, 2006)

In order to support your families as they work to ensure that their children compare most favorably, giving them a method or strategy to achieve these kinds of differences is critical. This is where Play by Play and Talk it Up fit into the puzzle. Inspiring parents to practice these methods of supporting their child’s language development many times each day, is where the family support worker fits into the mix. Helping parents see into their child’s future is an important first step. Making connections to what they want for their child helps connect the important dots. Walking them through the pay-offs for the Daily Do’s reminds them why they want to do this important work. Todd Risley explains it best when he says,

“Whenever a parent simply talks more, or can be induced to talk more, most of the extra talk has to be descriptive and conversational. As commentary and conversation increase, business talk will stay constant and the parent’s ratio or ‘parenting style’ will automatically improve.” (Risley & Hart, 2006)

The hardest part of Play by Play for parents of young infants is often getting past the idea that since the baby doesn’t talk…the caregivers don’t really need to talk to them. Help parents understand that the research indicates a very clear link between receptive language experiences in those early months and years and expressive language practice. Children of the most talkative families express themselves over 600 times an hour by age three, compared to the children of the least talkative families studied who by age three were only expressing themselves less than 200 times an hour. (Risley & Hart, 2006) By the time they start preschool, children whose families talked the most to them exhibit three times the expressive language of those who don’t. These kinds of language differences have been directly linked to intellectual outcomes and accomplishments. (Hart & Risley, 1999)

Parents from advantaged backgrounds tend to pass on a pattern of language achievement that will be repeated for generations to come, but in many of the family subcultures in our work, those first 15,000 hours of the baby’s life is lacking the kind of child-directed language interactions that really make a difference. In order to change this, we must “focus on teaching parents how to capitalize on those waking moments of their babies lives with activities and conversation hour after hour, day after day, month after month from the very beginning.” (Risley & Hart, 2006)

 

 

 

Works Cited

Hart, B., & Risley, T. (2003, Spring). The early catasrophe: The 30 million word gap by age 3. American Educator, pp. 4-9.

Hart, B., & Risley, T. R. (1995). Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experience of Young American Children. Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co.

Hart, B., & Risley, T. R. (1999). The Social World of Children Learning to Talk. Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookings Publishing Co.

Risley, T. R., & Hart, B. (2006). Promoting early language development. In N. F. Watt, C. Ayoub, R. H. Bradley, J. Puma, & W. A. LeBoeuf, The crisis in youth mental health: Critical issues and effective programs, Volume 4, Early intervention programs and policies. (pp. 83-88). Westport, CT: Praeger.

As always, feel free to email any topic suggestions or questions to danabroadway@greatkidsinc.net . Be sure to add Great Vine ideas to the subject line of the email.

 

Recent Posts

Giving Yourself (and Others) Grace

“Can I play the drums again?” they asked. Without giving it a moment of thought, a “no” came out of my mouth. It wasn’t the most convincing ‘no’ ⸺ more of a feeble reaction to the extra effort this activity would require when my patience was already thin. To this child, that no from their warm-hearted aunt sounded negotiable, and the lure of the shiny drum kit won over.

read more

Messy Fun Makes Healthy Brains

As I settle in to write this evening, the blue sky is fading to dark, and the evidence of a busy day lies scattered amongst my home. Stacked dishes fill the kitchen sink, toys decorate the living room floor, and dirty laundry overflows from every hamper.

read more

Growing Resilience

 Why am I talking about trees, you might wonder? Well, yesterday’s incident got me thinking about how unexpected storms can also come up in life, and if we, our families, and our communities are healthy and resilient, we’re in a better place to withstand these pressures and thrive.

read more

Share a Meal…Spread the Love

March is finally here! If you’re like me, you’re eager for this month to arrive. I’m happy to welcome longer days, warmer weather, and a brand-new season. One of the ways my family celebrates the budding trees and blooming flowers is by firing up the grill. You can often find us stacking shish kabobs with colorful peppers, slices of sweet onion, and juicy chunks of pineapple.

read more

Beautiful Bonds Last a Lifetime

Almost a decade later, when I reflect on this memory, I can still feel this parent’s presence. At that moment, nothing else mattered in the entire world to this parent. It almost seemed as if time was standing still. Looking back on this memory, it’s obvious what was happening right before my eyes. This parent was fully present with their infant. A secure attachment relationship was forming.

read more

Walking Your Talk

I paused at the entrance to the trail, double-checking that I was prepared for the unknown.  Water, check.  Shoes tied, check. Trail map, check.  I took a deep breath and my first steps into uncertain terrain.  Equal parts eager and apprehensive. 

read more

Growing Great Kids®

Why Choose Great Kids?

Never any recurring licensing fees

Proven Success

Over 37,000 people have been trained to use the Great Kids curricula

Protective Factors – GGK Constructs

Research informed constructs embedded in the Protective Factors Framework

Alignment with Head Start

The Growing Great Kids Home Based Curricula Series exceeds all Head Start Curriculum requirements

Evidenced Based Research

As evidenced by seven independent evaluations, the GGK Curriculum produces outstanding results

Specialized Training Programs 

On-site and virtual training options available

Healthy Families America

The Growing Great Kids curriculum aligns with and builds upon the HFA model approach